Antonello's Theft: Mafia Links and Internal Complicity Not Ruled Out. Report About the Van Denied


The Messina District Attorney’s Office continues to investigate the theft of Antonello’s paintings. Investigators are pursuing several leads, ranging from inside collusion to the possible involvement of criminal organizations. Meanwhile, reports that the van used in the getaway had been found have been denied: it was not the gang’s van. The four security guards, meanwhile, have been placed on leav

The Messina Public Prosecutor’s Office has launched an intensive investigation following the theft of the panels by Antonello da Messina. The current tally from the heist indicates that four works remain missing out of the six that were initially stolen. The thieves managed to steal the central panel of the San Gregorio Polyptych, depicting the Madonna and Child Enthroned, the two side panels depicting the Annunciation—which are also integral parts of the same polyptych—and a rare opistograph panel featuring the Madonna and Child giving a blessing, with a Franciscan in adoration on the front, and a Christ in Piety on the reverse. During the chaotic stages of their escape, the criminals abandoned on the edge of a low boundary wall, near the “Maria Accascina” Regional Museum, two other panels belonging to the San Gregorio Polyptych—namely, the figures of Saint Gregory and Saint Benedict—which were subsequently recovered by law enforcement thanks to reports from several citizens.

Messina’s chief prosecutor, Antonio D’Amato, who is coordinating the investigation into aggravated theft, made statements yesterday on TG1 outlining an investigative framework open to multiple scenarios. The judicial authorities are carefully examining various leads, “including that of possible internal complicity,” said D’Amato, “as the prosecutor’s office is also scrutinizing security lapses—or rather, those of the security personnel.” Among the elements under scrutiny are the procedures followed by security personnel and any flaws in the control systems. Furthermore, the hypothesis that the mafia—which has historically been interested in works of art—may be involved behind an operation of this magnitude, which requires planning and logistics, has not been ruled out.

Antonello da Messina, Polyptych of Saint Gregory: Madonna and Child or the Rosary, with Saints Gregory and Benedict, the Announcing Angel, and the Virgin (1473; panel, 170 x 203 cm; Messina, Accascina Regional Museum)
Antonello da Messina, Polyptych of Saint Gregory: Madonna and Child or of the Rosary between Saints Gregory and Benedict, the Announcing Angel, and the Annunciate (1473; panel, 170 x 203 cm; Messina, Accascina Regional Museum)

One aspect of particular interest to investigators is the circumstances surrounding the discovery of the crime. The Messina Police Department released a recording of a call made to the 112 emergency number by several passersby. The caller, visibly shaken, reported the presence of paintings abandoned on an exterior wall, identifying them as works from the museum. The immediate response by the patrol car led to the recovery of the two panel paintings of St. Gregory and St. Benedict. According to Prosecutor D’Amato, the speed with which citizens raised the alarm, combined with the prompt network of checkpoints set up by the police, may have “deterred the perpetrators from crossing the Sicilian border,” D’Amato reported. This, however, is a hypothesis that the District Attorney’s Office is currently investigating.

In parallel with the on-site search operations, forensic experts are engaged in meticulous analysis. Every trace found inside the museum and on the recovered works is carefully cataloged. The break-in, which was carried out with remarkable speed, reportedly took place in just three minutes. Surveillance footage shows at least two individuals, their faces concealed by helmets, acting with determination. Despite the alarms going off as intended and the presence of security cameras, the security guards on duty at the time did not immediately grasp the gravity of the situation; it was only after law enforcement reported the discovery of the paintings that the staff on duty realized the theft had occurred.

In this regard, administrative proceedings have been initiated against the four security guards on duty during the night of August 15. The Sicilian Regional Department of Cultural Heritage is awaiting the official report from the museum director, Marisa Mercurio. Internal investigations revealed no irregularities in the shifts from the previous days, but the conduct during the break-in is now the subject of disciplinary proceedings. In the meantime, the individuals involved—regional employees and staff belonging to Servizi Ausiliari Sicilia—have been placed on leave, though the possibility of their dismissal has not been ruled out.

Antonello da Messina, Double-sided panel, recto, Madonna and Child with a Franciscan (1465–1470; tempera on wood, 16 x 11.9 cm; Messina, Accascina Regional Museum)
Antonello da Messina, Double-sided Panel, recto, Madonna and Child with a Franciscan (1465–1470; tempera on panel, 16 x 11.9 cm; Messina, Accascina Regional Museum)
Antonello da Messina, Double-sided panel, reverse side, Christ in Piety (1465–1470; tempera on panel, 16 x 11.9 cm; Messina, Accascina Regional Museum)
Antonello da Messina, Double-sided Panel, reverse side, Christ in Piety (1465–1470; tempera on panel, 16 x 11.9 cm; Messina, Accascina Regional Museum)

The gang’s modus operandi suggests a swift operation with no major initial missteps, but one that ended in a disorderly escape, as evidenced by the abandonment of the two panels. Entry through a side passage allowed the criminals to reach the secure display cases directly, which were smashed using a blunt object. The images captured are currently being analyzed in an attempt to identify physical characteristics or other distinguishing features of the perpetrators, although the fact that they were wearing helmets significantly complicates the identification process.

On the logistical front, investigators faced a setback: the van previously suspected of being used by the thieves for their escape was ruled out of the investigation after thorough checks, as it turned out not to be the vehicle used to commit the crime. However, the theory that the vehicle was switched in a blind spot not covered by surveillance cameras remains one of the main hypotheses on which the agents of the Carabinieri’s Special Unit for the Protection of Cultural Heritage are focusing their efforts. The issue of the alarm—which was in working order—remains shrouded in questions, particularly regarding the failure to promptly notify law enforcement.

Public attention is at its peak. The works by Antonello da Messina represent a heritage that is not only Sicilian but universal, and their disappearance is a profound blow to the cultural landscape. The District Attorney’s Office is working in close coordination with the various police forces, attempting to piece together a puzzle that, at the moment, has several unresolved aspects. The hope of recovering the four still-missing panels hinges on the investigative teams’ ability to close in on those responsible and to block any possible escape routes or hiding places for the stolen artwork.

Antonello's Theft: Mafia Links and Internal Complicity Not Ruled Out. Report About the Van Denied
Antonello's Theft: Mafia Links and Internal Complicity Not Ruled Out. Report About the Van Denied



Warning: the translation into English of the original Italian article was created using automatic tools. We undertake to review all articles, but we do not guarantee the total absence of inaccuracies in the translation due to the program. You can find the original by clicking on the ITA button. If you find any mistake,please contact us.